Survive: how POST students do against an armed suspect
For POST and training leads, from Scoring Tech
“I measured many of these students. They were earnest, hopeful, well-intended, but the lack of training using a shot timer was apparent.”
The difference between a 0.9 and a 1.2 second draw can be the difference between life and death, and between mission accomplishment and failure. Speed and accuracy both matter, and so does being consistent in both. This note shows what that looks like in real student data, using marksmanship measurement and a gunfight simulation.
Fighting “Bill”
These are results from a POST academy class about to graduate. Every student had passed their department’s qualification several times. We measured about 96 students, two classes of about 48, three times each. Each time they shot three rounds of the Bill Drill: six shots from low ready on their normal qualification target.
We then modeled each student against “Bill,” a made-up untrained armed criminal who is very concerned you might take his freedom. (The Bill Drill is the drill we ran. Bill is the suspect we modeled.) Bill already has his gun out and gets a first shot off in under a second. He hits a lethal area of the target, which is you, about 20% of the time at 7 yards. That 20% is a modeled assumption, not a measured figure.
Green dots are students who won more than 80% of the time against Bill in the simulation.
The graph shows speed to the first shot across the bottom and how consistent that time is up the side. Low and to the left is better here, which is the opposite of what we want when we shoot a group.
The green dots sit at about 1 second or faster, with very little variation. Even a 1.2 second draw is risky against Bill, because by then he has already shot once and is about to shoot again.
Faster is better. Hitting an area that stops a threat at once is always better. So why not measure both?
What most quals don’t measure
We know that faster, accurate draws are better. The harder part is convincing the people who sign off on the qual. Leadership needs a reason that matters to them, and a measure tied to survival can carry more weight than the student drop rate does.
Surviving a meeting with Bill becomes the goal. To get there, students have to hit Bill in a stopping area before he hits them, which points to a handful of marksmanship measures that combine accuracy with consistently fast speed. The outline is:
- Treat time and accuracy as equally important in a fight.
- Measure both, at scale.
- Simulate fighting a realistic threat thousands of times, and see who wins.
- Use the key numbers from those fights to build training, and to measure it, so it beats “Bill.”
These are the key measures:
- First shot time
- How consistent the first shot time is
- Shot-to-shot intervals (splits)
- How consistent the splits are
- The chance of a stopping hit, here a hit scored 8, 9 or 10, in the area most likely to stop a threat at once
Improving each one helps a student beat Bill. Being consistent in each gives them stable performance across thousands of simulated fights.
You can’t improve what you don’t measure. If your qual has generous par times, and you don’t measure first shots, shot intervals, or the chance of a hit at each distance, you can’t see any of this. To beat Bill, you want the most consistently fast, consistently accurate shooter, and to build that shooter you need to measure these things.
Next steps
Call us. We can talk about measurement and training, and maybe set up a test audit of your staff or a small sample of your students. We’ll go from there.
Not sure how to get your students to a consistent 1 second draw? Call us. We know how. Our trainers will come out and teach your team to build and measure 1 second shooters at scale, so your students beat Bill.
For the timeline behind this, read The Bill Drill Gunfight. To try shot timing on a qual you already shoot, read Time every shot in the qual you already shoot.
Thanks for reading!
Ken Nelson
CEO, ScoringTech
435-429-1703 · sales@scoringtech.com
Mon to Fri, 8am to 5pm MT. You’ll speak with our CEO, LEO Liaison, or DoD Liaison.